Skip to content
Article · 3 min read

Onsite popup offers to capture emails

What works & what missed. Second in a series of Black Friday leadup thoughts for Aussie ecommerce.

DilogBlack Friday series

“What is the best onsite popup to get an email?” It turns out early access and FOMO can get a better response than either gamification or a straight discount.

With Black Friday, there’s a lot on the line. There were $23.8bn of purchases in the 2025 BF 2 week period (via CommBank), and 47% of Australian shoppers start Christmas buying 1-3 months ahead with a focus on that weekend (Monash ACRS). Getting as many people as possible aware early and in the door is crucial.

So for retailers currently at 6 weeks out to the big day, increasing the potential eDM pool is a focus. An onsite email capture pop-up can be a key driver. There are a lot of approaches, so we wanted to see what type of pop-up offer to customers actually earns its place.

We built a simulated skincare brand called Halcyra and ran a Dilog customer simulation panel, with different cohorts, through a simple scenario: a site visit on mobile, late October, a pop-up appears with three options.

  1. Give your email for 10% off

  2. take a spin on a wheel

  3. Get early access to the Black Friday sale.

Halcyra mobile popup with a serum bottle, headed "10% off your first order", with an email field and a Get my 10% button.
10% off, the normal popup for most nowadays…
Halcyra mobile popup headed "Spin for a Black Friday head start", with a prize wheel offering discounts, free shipping or a free lip balm, an email field and a Spin the wheel button.
Temu style gamification!
Halcyra mobile popup with a serum bottle, headed "Black Friday, a week early", offering sale access from Friday 20 November, with an email field and a Get early access button.
FOMO and an offer of time…

73% went for early access. Only 9% took the discount.

More people chose to close the pop-up and browse the site (14%) than took the discount. Among quality-focused shoppers where price wasn’t the primary driving factor, that was 23%.

The reasons were pretty consistent across the panel. Planning and budgeting came up for 68% of respondents. More time to plan things out and get in early on the items that they wanted, as well as not having to worry about things selling out before they could get it. Worrying about things selling out came up for 45%. A few people said the discount felt small relative to what a proper Black Friday sale would offer – one panellist called 10% off “a bit stingy.”

Two panel quotes. Lydia V. says a head start appeals to her need for control and planning. Josephine E. says a head start is helpful and that 10% off "feels a bit stingy".

For gamification, only 5% were that interested in the spin-to-win wheel. The main reasons why? The panelists in both cohorts (in this study divided on different ends of price sensitivity) giving feedback on not trusting it or finding it a bit irritating.

Giving people a head start, rather than a small saving or a dopamine hit, worked. For everyone that’s seen your competitor’s start date for a Black Friday sale get earlier every year, this makes sense.

This is one brand, one panel – directional rather than definitive. This is also a test on a customer simulation panel of Australian customers, so if you are outside Australia behaviour and motivations would obviously differ. However, in late October the mindset is already there. People are planning, not browsing for a random deal. This aligns well with overall concerns of affordability, as well as the CHOICE 2025 finding of consumer skepticism with Black Friday, showing 52% of Aussies think BF discounts aren’t always genuine.

If you haven’t already adjusted your popup in the leadup to Black Friday, it would certainly be worth a test to see if early access gives you a higher signup rate of those crucial shoppers leading into November.

If you want to sense check your own creatives or compare against a competitor, take advantage of the free trial at Dilog to run your own testing.

Try it with your own question

Start your free trial and put your first question to a real customer panel in minutes.

Start your free trial